Specialists do not grow on trees
The discussions on the subject of skills shortages are always surprisingly contradictory: While some claim that there is no shortage at all, others complain that they cannot find suitable employees - and are happy to start “hip” personnel marketing campaigns, which are thrown away in a hectic and desperate manner To attract specialists in particular.
In reality, companies that complain about a shortage of skilled workers are often even to blame for their own dilemma. And they could even solve it themselves. I remember an event where I attended speakers such as HR scientist Jutta Rump or Gerd Zirka from the Institute for Employment Research on the podium of a meeting by Young IT Professionals (YITP) in Heidelberg.
The solution to the skills shortage problem: Get active yourself
Opinions differed as to how companies can attract and retain skilled workers, but at the end of the day a standing crystallized out: skilled workers are generally not readily available, how many companies want them to, they do not grow on trees ,
Rather, companies that lack well-qualified employees have to take action themselves instead of waiting for suitable applications. One possibility for this could be your own trainee programs. And by that I don't mean, hip employer branding videos and other advertising gimmicks to somehow attract applicants, but training and further education measures that are becoming more and more an employer branding trend anyway.
Is education and training too complicated?
Because honestly, it is about making a virtue out of necessity: in many areas, the necessary expertise is already so new that there is no longer any standardized vocational training. The solution: Simply train the employees themselves.
Strangely enough, one often hears the word “shortage of skilled workers” from companies that find it too complicated to train employees or who think they do not have the right structures for this.
Training with 50 employees
Mediafix GmbH in Cologne is taking different paths: the company digitizes old film reels, video cassettes and slide photos. Since the digitization devices were specially developed for the StartUp, new employees have to be trained:
"We have created a five-day apprenticeship that ends with an exam to become a media digitizer," explains Mediafix founder Hans-Günter Herrmann. "Contents include material knowledge, quality guidelines and the operation of the devices."
Sound training = better service
Twelve new employees are trained each year, and the trend is rising. Herrmann does not see the training as an additional effort:
"Since we operate in a niche, the necessary specialist knowledge is simply not available on the job market." But the training also helps to reduce costs. "We have created standardized processes and can therefore offer a very affordable offer," says Herrmann.
Binding standards are important
The IHK-certified CrowdFunding Manager (in) of IHK München in cooperation with the German Crowdsourcing Association is also committed to binding standards.
"We offer consultants and experts in companies a solid basis to provide holistic advice on crowd funding and to realistically assess the risk associated with campaigns," explains Thomas Kölbl, Head of Seminars at the IHK Academy in Munich and Upper Bavaria, explaining the motivation for the course.
Set standards in the job market
He clarifies: “On eight seminar days, the participants work on the theoretical basics as well as their own project and at the end complete a certificate test. Our trainer Dr. Michael Gebert supports them with his practical experience, ”says Kölbl.
This shows that companies can easily create their own training and further education. If they work together with institutions that operate nationwide, such as the IHK, they can even set standards in the labor market.
TV presenter Tobias Schlegel as a paramedic
However, there is not only one qualification problem when it comes to the shortage of skilled workers. Some fires are simply unattractive because of poor pay for inhumane working hours. This results in a tangible image problem from which sectors such as helping and social professions or tourism suffer.
But that could be remedied with very simple means. This includes, for example, that in addition to better pay, the positive, meaningful aspects of the work would be emphasized more. TV host Tobias Schlegel caused a big surprise last week with his announcement that he would quit his job and want to work as a paramedic in the future. His motive: to do something socially relevant.
High satisfaction from social professions
Social professions, for example in nursing care, do not necessarily have the best image. Nevertheless, employees often draw great satisfaction from their activities. This also seems to have been Schlegel's motive for the change.
Hans Pauli from Inzell, Bavaria, changed from a leading position at Deutsche Telekom to a full-time position in the management of the location at the Bergwacht Bavaria, where he had been working as a volunteer for 26 years. There he is now responsible for the maintenance and maintenance of the digital radio stations of the authorities, which was put into operation at the G7 summit 2015.
Image and reality
Not an easy job, as he says, "you see a lot of bad things". While it always goes well in TV series like “Die Bergretter”, it is unfortunately not the case in reality. Spectacular helicopter and rappel actions would normally be much more prudent: "The lives and safety of pilots and helicopters take precedence," said Pauli.
Presumably these television series contribute a lot to the heroic image of social professions - while the bad image has different reasons: Often simply an adequate pay is missing, which is appropriate to the social relevance of these occupations.
Lobby work is required
According to Portalvergleichvergleich.com, the average salary for social facilities is an average of 2414 Euro gross.
Meanwhile, senior managers with an average of 1715 Euro per month are at the end of the scale, while managers earn about 3000 Euro. Here, a lot of lobbying and image work is needed to remedy the situation.
Companies - blame for their own dilemma?
Tourism is also an industry that is badly affected by the lack of skilled workers due to its image. The successful employer like Markus Gutheinz, who has just been awarded the Instructor of the Year award in Austria, shows that there is another way.
His recipe: he paid the employees of his hotel “Jungbrunn” every hour of overtime, provided apartments, food and work clothes - and also further training: in addition to the vocational school, the trainees also learned specialist knowledge and soft skills in their own academy.
Fluctuation belongs to it
While many companies shy away from investing in employees because they are afraid of leaving, Gutheinz is relaxed: “Fluctuation is one of them in tourism. We even motivate people to gain experience in other houses, ”he says.
This is worthwhile: The hotel has long since established itself as an employer brand, the employees come from 14 nations to work in the remote Tannheimer Valley.
The “Jungbrunn” as a reference is worth a lot. And some come back years later. "The employees are a mirror of the company philosophy," explains the hotelier, who has recognized one thing: appreciation for employees is the best personnel marketing.
The discussion on the topic
As expected, it has to do that Article already given a number of comments and reader reactions in the world. They show how great the frustration on the part of job seekers is. So it says: This is all just imagegedöhns. the labor market has been so diluted by Hartz4 that the now-promoted multilingual staff can be found under 12 € the hour. If garnix helps more is jmd from Poland, which work even for 10 € / h. There is no shortage of skilled workers! Appreciation is the best HR marketing ?? - Ha, ha, good joke
We have enough good people in the companies but performance and effort are simply not rewarded. The more you show performance and commitment, the more people are generally used and exploited.
We have enough young people looking for a job, if they are lucky they get a temporary job at a pittance.
These are the facts on the subject !! Appreciation? There are still enough companies that run entire departments with temporary workers thanks to the Hartz shame and these are all specialists. But as long as the state makes that possible, nothing will change. Everything is not entirely wrong, however, the worthy commentators have probably overlooked that the above example comes from Austria, where the employment law is still a lot more employee-friendly.
In addition, the article does not deny these facts: However, there are still small and medium-sized companies that still complain about a shortage of skilled workers despite the circumstances you have described. The article gives reasons for this and shows solutions, there are further solutions in the article The fairy tale of skills shortage - A question of perspective.
More knowledge - PDF download, eCourses or personal advice
Offline download: Download this text as PDF - Read usage rights, Because we do not automatically submit the title of this text for privacy reasons: When buying in "interests" the title register if support is needed. After buying text exclusively Download at this URL (please save).
Your eCourse on Demand: Choose your personal eCourse on this or another desired topic, As a PDF download. Up to 30 lessons with each 4 learning task + final lesson. Please enter the title under "interests". Alternatively, we are happy to put together your course for you or offer you a personal regular eMailCourse including supervision and certificate - all further information!
Consultant packages: You want to increase your reach or address applicants as an employer? For these and other topics we offer special Consultant packages (overview) - For example, a personal phone call (price is per hour).